St. Croix St. Thomas: Which is Better for You?

Derek Dellinger portrait.
Derek Dellinger
Review author
27.08.2022 16:24
last update

The St Croix versus St Thomas destination argument only exists because these are two of the most beautiful vacation hotspots. Are wondering which is better St. Croix or St. Thomas? They are both home to numerous historical landmarks. Let's get into more details on both destinations.

St Croix is an island in the Caribbean Sea, the largest of the US Virgin Islands. It covers a total area of about 82 square meters and its highest point of elevation is 1,165 meters. It's also nicknamed the twin city because of its two towns Frederiksted, which is situated in the western part, and Christiansted which is located in the northeastern part. It has a population of roughly 41,000 people. St Thomas on the other hand is also one of the US Virgin Islands and home to 43,000 people. It has a land area of 32 square meters and is home to numerous historical sites and numerous resorts. Hence, why it attracts so many visitors from all around the world.

With the similarities in the population of people, location, cost of living, hotels, resorts, and adventures, it is no surprise that St Croix and St Thomas often pose a problem to intending vacationers.

Beach in st Thomas.

Most popular hotel booking services

Best booking
Book your
perfect holiday and enjoy our great discounts on hotels, homes, flights and activities.
Less Hassle, More Travel
Over a billion
Reviews & Contributions for Hotels, Attractions, Restaurants, and More
World’s most trusted travel advice
The Best
Hotels, Flights, Car Rentals & Accommodations
Save time, save money!

Best Time to Visit St. Croix and St. Thomas

The temperature in St Croix is between 72°F to 88°F with an average of 80°F every year. Overall, St Croix is hot, windy, and partly cloudy. Rainfall is mostly experienced around April 28 to mid-November, and less likely around the end of November to April 16. The total annual rainfall in St Croix is about 50 inches, with rainfall typically lasting for 10-15 minutes.

St Thomas has similar weather features too. The average temperature is between 72°F to 90°F, so, St Thomas is also hot, windy, and cool for most of the year. The average yearly precipitation here is about 3.2 inches per year. April to October is hotter in St Thomas, while the cooler months are between November to March.

So, on the best time to visit, St Croix vs St Thomas ends in a stalemate.

Resort in st Croix.

St. Croix vs St. Thomas: Average Hotel Price

St Croix or St Thomas are both suitable for averagely affordable trips. Hotels in St Croix range from 70 dollars to 200 dollars per night, depending on your choice. The hotels are usually 3-star or 4-star. While hotels are cheaper from July to October when the weather is very cool, booking a few months before your stay would also give you the best deals.

St Thomas has hotels that are relatively a little costlier because it's busier than St Croix and has more adventure. Here, hotels range from 90 dollars to 300 dollars. However, you can find cheaper hotels and transportation in September in St Thomas because of higher rainfall and wetter days around that time. November to January are usually the most expensive times to book hotels, but not surprisingly, you can find many visitors around, as no one wants their adventures limited by the rains.

Things to Do in St. Croix and St. Thomas

St Croix vs St Thomas is a tight competition when it comes to this. Buck Island in St Croix has one of the most gorgeous beaches in the world. You could take a boat ride to the island then walk on the beach and even snorkel. You could also go to Point Udall, which is the first place the sun rises in the US. It is a particularly famous place during the new year festivities where you'll be the first to enter into the new year.

Rainbow beach is a spectacular place to play and relax either by yourself or with a group. Sandy Point National Wildlife refuge is also a place to see before you leave the safe havens of St Croix. You could go see the turtles there in clear waters. However, the refuge usually closes for turtle nesting season, so check before you go.

There are numerous activities to check out in St Thomas. You could explore great depths by scuba-diving in what many know as one of the clearest waters in the world while looking at the beautiful coral reefs and penetrating shipwrecks underwater. If you do not know how to scuba dive, there are instructors available to teach you. The historic 99 steps are also situated here. You could take a walk on these old steps which were built by the Danes, and go zip lining in St Thomas - Zip lining over the beautiful island which starts from St Thomas mountain and extends to the other side of the island.

Water in st Thomas.

Conclusion: Which is Better St. Croix or St. Thomas?

If you have been confused about which is better St Croix or St Thomas, we hope this has been helpful to you.

St Croix is a lot quieter with fewer tourist attractions than St Thomas. However, there are numerous bars and hotels, and thus, more adventure in St Thomas - maybe that's because it's called “The Gateway to the Caribbean”. Due to the bustle in St Thomas, things are also a little pricier than St Croix.

Overall, when you consider St. Croix or St. Thomas are at similar cost. By the way, in St you'll get more fun and adventure.


Is St. Croix or St. Thomas better?

There is no clear answer to this question as it depends on what you are looking for in a vacation destination. St. Croix is known for its lush landscapes and pristine beaches, while St. Thomas is more developed with a lively nightlife scene. Ultimately, the best island for you will depend on your personal preferences.

What is the difference between St. Croix and St. Thomas?

St. Croix is known for its beaches, rainforests, and heritage sites while St. Thomas is known for its duty-free shopping and lively nightlife. St. Croix is less developed than St. Thomas but offers a more laid-back vibe. If you're looking to relax on the beach and explore some history, St. Croix is the perfect choice. If you're looking for a livelier atmosphere with more shopping and nightlife options, St. Thomas is the island for you.

Is St. Croix more expensive than St. Thomas?

The cost of living on St. Croix is generally higher than on St. Thomas. Prices for groceries and dining out are similar to those in the mainland United States, while housing costs can be quite high. St. Croix also has a few luxury resorts that cater to tourists, so prices for accommodations and activities can be expensive as well. However, there are ways to save money on St. Croix, such as by shopping at local markets and avoiding the most touristy areas. Overall, St. Croix is more expensive than St. Thomas, but it doesn't have to be prohibitively so.

Is the weather better in St. Croix or St. Thomas?

The weather is better in St. Croix. St. Croix has an average temperature of 82 degrees Fahrenheit, while St. Thomas has an average temperature of only 80 degrees Fahrenheit. St. Croix also has more sunny days than St. Thomas. St. Croix averages about 240 sunny days per year, while St. Thomas only averages about 210 sunny days per year. St. Croix is also drier than St. Thomas. St. Croix receives an average of only 20 inches of rain per year, while St. Thomas receives an average of 30 inches of rain per year.

Are beaches better in St. Croix or St. Thomas?

If you're looking for a more natural beach experience, St. Croix is the better choice. The island has miles of unspoiled beaches, including secluded coves and hidden bays. St. Croix's beaches are also less crowded than those on St. Thomas. So, if you're looking for a quiet beach where you can relax and enjoy the natural beauty of the Caribbean, St. Croix is the better choice. If you're looking for a more developed beach experience, St. Thomas is the better choice. The island has several large beaches that are well-equipped with amenities like restaurants, bars, and shops. St. Thomas' beaches are also more popular, so they can be crowded during the peak season. But, if you're looking for a beach where you can find everything you need in one place, St. Thomas is the better choice.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Derek Dellinger
Review author
your name
your mail
please rate
evaluation of the article on a five-point scale
message text
messages are sent after being
checked by a moderator